WSJ Tries To Convince Readers There's No Japanese Nuclear Crisis

Last Updated on Tuesday, 15 March 2011 14:21 Tuesday, 15 March 2011 13:11

Written by Giovanni

5 Comments

Nuclear meltdown 101

What Part of "Nuclear Meltdown" Does The Wall Street Journal Not Understand?

WSJ Says Don't Be Afraid of Radiation: Japanese Prime Minister Disagrees

Maybe the Wall Street Journal just has very bad timing, or maybe it is part of the nuclear industry panic that the meltdown at several Japanese nuclear reactors will mean the end of the myth that nuclear is clean energy. The WSJ headline came just one day before the third reactor exploded, releasing radiation that is now floating over Tokyo, says it all:

Japan Does Not Face Another Chernobyl

The containment structures appear to be working, and the latest reactor designs aren't vulnerable to the coolant problem at issue here.

True, this is not another Chernobyl, yet. It is a Fukushima, where four of six reactors have exploded, are in the process of a meltdown, and where all but 50 workers have been evacuated. Radiation levels at the plant as so high that they could kill an exposed human in less than five hours.

Other facts quoted in the article are laughable, as Tucker resorts to quaint analogies to argue that a China Syndrome meltdown isn't possible:

"The core of a nuclear reactor operates at about 550 degrees Fahrenheit, well below the temperature of a coal furnace and only slightly hotter than a kitchen oven."

The facts: Core temps in a controlled nuclear reaction are 550 Fahrenheit. Uncontrolled? The graphite in Chernobyl glowed red at 700 Celsius (that's 1300 Fahrenheit). But comparing a nuclear reaction to your kitchen oven is a misleading (and stupid) analogy. All that is required is for the containment vessel to break during a meltdown.

Since hydrogen can form from zirconium rods, an explosion rupturing the containment vessel is probable. Once this happens large quantities of reactivity will likely be released. There is no need for a "China Syndrome" meltdown through the bottom of the containment vessel.

The issue is not so much the heat as it is the damage done by the earthquake and Tsunami, which has allowed the nuclear material to lose coolant when the generators failed. This has led to the cascading effects of the coolant boiling off, the buildup of pressure from hydrogen and the resulting explosions as the hydrogen ignited, exposing the core and releasing radiation into the atmosphere.

"If anything unusual occurs, the control rods immediately drop, shutting off the nuclear reaction."

The facts: Efforts to fill the leaking reactor with seawater are so far failing, and the nuclear rods are exposed, which may lead to a total meltdown.

"If a meltdown does occur in Japan, it will be a disaster for the Tokyo Electric Power Company but not for the general public. Whatever steam releases occur will have a negligible impact."

The facts: As of Tuesday, March 15, the Japanese government disagrees with that comment, as it said it is very likely the population will be contaminated by radioactivity released. Also, the US Navy has moved away from the area after finding out its crew had been contaminated after only brief exposure.

Here are some more facts about what a nuclear meltdown looks like. Too bad the Wall Street Journal did not consult the facts before publishing Mr. Tuckers fictional opinion piece.

Tags:

japan nuclear crisis

Comments

0 #5 WWW.VOGUEBUYBUY.COM 2011-10-27 08:50

Welcome to: http://www.voguebuybuy.com is specialized in online service on ugg Jordan air max

oakland raiders $30--39; Ed Hardy AF JUICY POLO Bikini $18; Handbags (Coach lv fendi d&g)

$30 T shirts (Polo ,edhardy,lacost e) $15 Jean(True Religion,edhard y,coogi) $30 Sunglasses

(Oakey,coach,gu cci,Armaini) $14 New era cap $14 wallets (LV D&G CHANEL GUCCI COACH)$14

ACCEPT PYAPAL PAYMENT AND CREDIT CARDS DELIVERY TO YOU DOOR TO DOOR ==

http://www.voguebuybuy.com ====

Quote

0 #4 food recipes 2011-10-25 08:18

I like your blog very much and thank you for waking people up with all the new concepts you are offering. Can you show me where can I get some more info on this matter?

Quote

0 #3 2011-07-02 01:49

jch although, we've said it before,Office Professional Plus 2010 Activation, I'll say it again. We currently have about 4,300 open positions at Microsoft across all groups and discipline s. Roughly 1,Office Ultimate 2007,500 of those are what we would consider industry product development positions

Quote

0 #2 2011-04-07 00:40

For those of you who are purchasing Taps,we realize that this is one of the most important purchasing decisions you will make. You have made the best choice in choosing one of our Bathroom Sink Taps,Kitchen Taps or Shower Taps etc, as they are constructed of the highest grade materials to ensure that your new Taps lasts forever. You can be confident in your purchase as each item comes with a no hassle 30 day return privilege.

Quote

0 #1 2011-03-16 10:44

Our prayers go out to all the Japanese people. Shame on the Wall Street Journal and the nuclear industry and lobbyists, trying to convince us in the middle of the biggest disaster on earth that the most dangerous and expensive way ever invented to boil water is the only way to stop global warming. If you think they would let their families live next to these plants, I have a nice beachfront property in Japan I'd like to sell you, with a great view of an exploding nuclear plant!

Quote

Refresh comments list
RSS feed for comments to this post.

Add comment

JComments

WSJ Tries To Convince Readers There's No Japanese Nuclear Crisis

Comments

Add comment

Related Urban Myths, Legends and Rumors

NYC Star Maps

New York City's #1 Map to the Stars Homes!

UrbanMyths Twitter

Latest News

Comments

Top Searches

Latest Tags

Web Design Prices

Like it? Share it!